1. Skip to navigation
  2. Skip to content
  3. Skip to sidebar

Mises Economics Blog

Archive: B.K. Marcus

voluntary socialism versus human nature

February 6, 2010 4:09 PM by B.K. Marcus

Kibbutz Givat Oz

I lived half a year on a kibbutz back in the late 1980s, just as the intifada was starting.

For most of that time, I was the "shotef sirim" — the pot scrubber. For me, it was a proud title. It was the one kitchen job they wouldn't let women do (something about the weight of the pots or the height of the top shelves), so I spent the work days surrounded by women — but with my own little domain behind the oversized sinks and the power spray of hot and cold water.

Now I learn from the Financial Times ("The rise of the capitalist kibbutz") that "Tasks that used to be performed by kibbutzniks regardless of their education and background — such as washing the dishes — are today largely the preserve of hired workers from outside the community."

As the article's title implies, that's not the only change confronting the kibbutzim, the once-upon-a-time bastion of voluntary socialism — the "proof," as some of us once claimed, that "it worked."

As kibbutznik-turned-economics-professor Omer Moav argues,

the kibbutz movement was always destined to fail. It worked, he says, only as long as kibbutzniks enjoyed a standard of living broadly comparable to, if not better than, the Israeli average. "People respond to incentives. We are happy to work hard for our own quality of life, we like our independence," he says. "It is all about human nature — and a socialist system like the kibbutz does not fit human nature."

Bookmark/Share | Comments (17)


More Literature of Liberty

February 4, 2010 10:10 AM by B.K. Marcus

The Driver, ePubSatan's Bushel, ePubThe Cinder Buggy, ePubHarangue, ePubTime Will Run Back, ePub

We recommend Adobe Digital Editions for reading ePub (ebook) files. For an online ePub reader, we recommend O'Reilly's Bookworm. With Stanza, you can read ePub files on your iPhone or iPod Touch. With Calibre, you can convert an ePub file to other formats. Calibre will also let you put these ebooks on your Kindle.

Bookmark/Share | Comments (13)


The Libertarian Tradition: Isabel Paterson

February 2, 2010 10:06 AM by B.K. Marcus

Isabel Paterson
Isabel Paterson

Today is Ayn Rand's birthday, but the Libertarian Tradition podcast dedicated two episodes to Rand last month. Today we learn about her friend and (as it turns out) her mentor, Isabel Paterson (1886–1961). Paterson was a journalist, author, political philosopher, and a leading literary critic of her day. Along with Rose Wilder Lane and Ayn Rand, she is one of the three founding mothers of American libertarianism.

Bookmark/Share | Comments (2)


Three New Audiobooks
2010.01.27 | Comments (6)

one ring to rule them all
2010.01.26 | Comments (9)

Professor Raico on iTunes U
2010.01.25 | Comments (4)

Podcast Toasts Lysander Spooner on His Birthday
2010.01.19 | Comments (4)

Professor Cantor on iTunes U
2010.01.18 | Comments (1)

Wondolowski's Two Cents
2010.01.11 | Comments (3)

Mises.org: Kindle Edition
2010.01.08 | Comments (6)

Rothbard's History of Thought in Audio
2010.01.05 | Comments (12)

Read ePub just in Firefox
2009.12.26 | Comments (11)

10 obsolete technologies to kill in 2010
2009.12.26 | Comments (15)

Timeless Wisdom from Hans Sennholz
2009.12.10 | Comments (6)

Big Daddy
2009.12.08 | Comments (5)

Coming Soon to iTunes U
2009.12.02 | Comments (6)

more ebooks
2009.11.16 | Comments (9)

An invitation to have the "Mises" blog featured on The Christian Science Monitor
2009.10.26 | Comments (75)

How did Baldy Harper slip down the memory hole?
2009.09.29 | Comments (3)

Turgot on profit
2009.06.23 | Comments (5)

Economics in 2 Paragraphs
2009.05.08 | Comments (18)

Great Artists Steal?
2009.02.02 | Comments (7)

The Truth Is Out There
2008.11.13 | Comments (1)

America's Great Depression, 50% Off at Audible.com
2008.11.12 | Comments (2)

Semantic Tools and Faulty Nomenclature
2008.06.28 | Comments (16)

Two New Audio Essays
2008.06.20 | Comments (2)

synonym of imbecility
2008.06.19 | Comments (9)

Seasteading
2008.06.14 | Comments (11)

to deal with men as the breeder deals with his cattle
2008.05.27 | Comments (3)

The Driver: The Human Story Behind the Economic History
2008.05.21 | Comments (2)

The Evolution of an Anti-Anti-Communist
2008.04.01 | Comments (5)

The War Against the South and Its Consequences
2008.03.20 | Comments (10)

The Road to Civil War
2008.03.19 | Comments (4)

Civic Religion
2008.02.19 | Comments (7)

Abolition: Who Deserved Compensation for What?
2008.02.04 | Comments (17)

Rothbard on the value of The Value of Money
2008.01.11 | Comments (0)

Best Book on Economics since Human Action
2008.01.10 | Comments (4)

Why Cicero?
2008.01.03 | Comments (0)

Free Audiobook: Gold, Peace, and Prosperity
2008.01.01 | Comments (4)

Free Audiobook: "The Market for Liberty"
2007.12.26 | Comments (9)

Rooting for Old Man Potter
2007.12.24 | Comments (30)

HBD, Ludwig
2007.09.29 | Comments (1)

Interesting Timing
2007.07.06 | Comments (0)

inflation in the afterlife?
2007.06.18 | Comments (2)

Statistics: Achilles' Heel of Government
2007.05.30 | Comments (2)

Rothbardian Rights Theory, circa 1959
2007.05.18 | Comments (1)

Is Spider-Man the alternative to law-enforcement socialism?
2007.05.15 | Comments (4)

BUSINESS WEEK warns against privatizing roads
2007.05.02 | Comments (9)

Why Not Capital Day?
2007.05.01 | Comments (38)

Left Coast Road Socialism and the Market-friendly Governor
2007.04.30 | Comments (4)

Fairness with Your Coffee?
2007.04.23 | Comments (2)

The Tepid Movement Before Mises
2007.04.12 | Comments (6)

Was Rothbard an Auromaniac?
2007.03.06 | Comments (12)

Was Sumner an Anarchist?
2007.02.23 | Comments (9)

Did FDR Forget The Forgotten Man?
2007.02.23 | Comments (3)

The Socialist Calculator Debate
2007.02.15 | Comments (6)

The Economics of Groundhog Day (the movie)
2007.02.02 | Comments (3)

Viral Liberty
2007.01.30 | Comments (1)

Industrial Media
2007.01.28 | Comments (2)

Ethics of Liberty Audiobook Podcast
2007.01.12 | Comments (19)

Curmudgeonly Wishes for the New Year
2006.12.31 | Comments (4)

The Swedish Central Bank Prize in Economics
2006.10.13 | Comments (14)

Fighting for the truth
2006.09.29 | Comments (3)

FaNL audio, chapter 2: "The Libertarian Creed"
2006.05.19 | Comments (0)

Why Gold?
2006.03.28 | Comments (32)

Ron Paul Predicts Impeachment
2006.03.03 | Comments (25)

March Is Rothbard Month
2006.03.02 | Comments (0)

"an affirmation of permanence"
2006.02.04 | Comments (5)

Batman versus the State
2006.02.02 | Comments (4)

Rothbardian Baby
2006.01.24 | Comments (4)

How the Stewardess Lost Her Stripes
2006.01.04 | Comments (17)

Ludwig's Mother: In Her Own Words
2005.12.09 | Comments (1)

Ludwig's Mother Remembers
2005.12.05 | Comments (3)

Listen to MU05!
2005.11.02 | Comments (0)

Mises quotes from the NYU seminar
2005.09.09 | Comments (2)

Concise Guide to Price Gouging
2005.09.02 | Comments (20)

blowing bubbles
2005.08.30 | Comments (3)

Shostak on Velocity
2005.08.19 | Comments (5)

Batman versus Capitalism
2005.07.29 | Comments (0)

free-market money cranks
2005.07.05 | Comments (3)

iTunes and the Mises.org Podcast
2005.07.01 | Comments (8)

The Economics and Emotions of the Minimum Wage
2005.04.14 | Comments (16)

The Concise Guide To Economics
2005.04.05 | Comments (6)

Economics for Actors
2005.02.09 | Comments (1)

Rothbard Speaks
2004.12.14 | Comments (1)

Captain-Capitalism!
2004.11.14 | Comments (2)

The Spectrum Should Be Private Property: The Economics, History, and Future of Wireless Technology
2004.10.28 | Comments (15)

libertarian socialism?
2004.10.21 | Comments (25)

Hernando de Soto to speak at UNC
2004.10.21 | Comments (5)

Google's World
2004.10.14 | Comments (6)

Paranoia versus Scholarship
2004.10.11 | Comments (0)

Afternoons with Ralph Raico
2004.09.28 | Comments (2)

Radio Free Rothbard
2004.09.28 | Comments (0)

Radio Free Germany
2004.09.23 | Comments (3)

Mises on Blood for Oil
2004.09.19 | Comments (3)

The Monetary Economics of Thurston Howell III
2004.08.31 | Comments (19)